Wednesday, October 12, 2022

Some thoughts ahead of the winter

Here is my reply to a comment under the last post:

"Buddy, you're awesome! I live in Nebraska (your neighbor) and I'm so scared to put my baby outside in the ground. She's 4 years old, I grew her from a seed. She's the only one that made it from the seed out of roughly 6-8.

What do you recommend? I'm incredibly attached to this tree so, yeah. Please help me lol"


One thing that you (and me) need to accept is that sequoias in Zone 5 is an indoors plant. It's an indoors plant that we expose to a hostile outdoors environment incompatible with its genetics. I can give you my best advice but the chances are slim for your sequoia to grow outside. Nobody said it was going to be easy though, so it's all good.

It appears that sequoias need to have more or less continuous access to liquid flowing water. They are 100% freeze intolerant for their root system. Any pot that had been frozen, they die. Last winter I had 6 sequoias in 2 gallon pots in an unheated shed. They were placed in a plastic tray with flat bucket heaters under the bottom of each pot. The tray was filled to about one inch depth with water. Water stayed mostly liquid during last winter since it was not a terrible winter like a few years back. However, a few times during the winter the temperature dropped enough to freeze the water completely for a few days in a row. I kept adding water and even placed a continuously blowing space heater directed at the tray. Being in a shed, they were protected from the blowing wind. However, they were not wrapped in any fabric or plastic. I could say that the soil in the pots got frozen out and only roots at the very bottom were exposed to liquid water throughout the winter. It was not enough. All 6 were dead by the following summer.

For the upcoming winter I am planning on protecting the trees with applying anti-desiccant to the needles with fabric and plastic wrapping, same way I did before. However, this time I will continue watering several select sequoias throughout the winter. My temperature sensor experiments from last two years showed that it's not terribly difficult to keep the temperature continuously above freezing at 1 foot depth with application of a thick layer of mulch. What was missing last winter was access to liquid water. I was hoping that enough snow would melt and trickle to the roots, but it appears it was not the case. My new plan is to water wrapped sequoias with excess warm water through a hose stuck in mulch a couple of times a month and especially during cold spells. I believe the trick is to keep feeder roots exposed to water continuously. Tap root alone is not going to do the trick. 

Long term survivability of sequoias in Zone 5 is questionable but one could imagine an engineering solution where water could be delivered under ground through some clever combination of heat pipes and water pipes that would melt the snow from above and deliver flowing water to the roots. Something to ponder about. 

My oldest surviving sequoias are 6 years old now. You would never say they are that old. They survive by being small, bush-like and fitting under a foam cone for winter. One overgrew the largest cone available at Menards but I forced it inside by folding the top. As a result it's still alive but many others that I was wrapping in fabric and plastic are dead. In general those foam cones work very well but by no means a guarantee of success. 

267, 6 years old, under 2 feet

My tallest but not the oldest sequoias are now about 7 foot tall. I have one that's 6'8" and another that's 7'2". 

365, 5 year old, 6'8" 

#365

A blast from the past: #365 in 2017:



#, 7'2"


10 comments:

  1. Putting my first sequoia through an Iowa winter! Just mulch, straw, and deep, deep roots for protection

    Expecting failure but attempting nonetheless with a unique process

    Love the blog and read it all before doing this! Will update if there is any success

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

      Delete
    2. At least spray it with anti-desiccant, something like "Needlehold" and water throughout winter

      Delete
    3. Without deep mulch, without antidesiccant, without watering, and without any covering besides the dead grass and straw around it, my sequoia survived and is growing again now (with some dieback obviously, but looking good)

      I really believe keeping things natural (no chemical fertilizer, only mycorrhizae and ASOS rooting bacteria), getting it in the ground as soon as possible (it was only inside growing in a 14in deep container for one winter [grew it to 8in in a few months indoors]), and getting the roots as deep as possible were the keys to success

      Focus on what you can't see and what you do see will be green!!

      Delete
  2. Thank you for your blog, pure gold! I'm planning to grow sequoias in Lithuania, it is Zone 5. What if to plant sequoias really deep? Like 1/2--2/3 of the tree height in the ground. After winter we can dig some soil out, and on winter put in back.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I would recommend putting mulch, leaves or some other loose material instead of soil. While the seedling are under 1 meter you can successfully bury a big part of or an entire smaller tree under that material. I would not recommend soil. Maybe loose peat moss would work but nothing heavy. You would damage the tree if it's really buried in soil. Also, after you put a sequoia in the ground and let the roots penetrate the soil you do not want to continue digging it out. The roots are very fragile and break very easily. You can re-plant a tree, I did so successfully once but after 2-3 years the root system becomes so large that it becomes unfeasible to move them.

      Delete
  3. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I have 2 in central Illinois. They are 5 years old. I water them weekly and lightly mulch in summer. In winter, I cover with an opaque plastic cone. The cone now goes on top of mulch and this year on top of mulch filled pots. They get some wind burn in winter but I don’t worry if they are partially exposed on the sides. They are 3 feet tall now and doing well. But we have had relatively mild winters the last few years

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hi!

    I have followed your work for a couple of years. Thank you for your work.

    Do you have any updates for 2023?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Updates are not good. All sequoias over 2 feet tall died.

      Boris

      Delete